holiday haters
Why be a hater: Lovers who dislike Valentine's Day
Feb 14, 2012 | 9:00 am
The fact that Valentine's Day is upon us causes most people to have one of two opposite reactions: Totally embracing this day to celebrate love, or feeling complete disdain for what seems a forced, manufactured "holiday."
And in case you think that most people who fall into the "anti-Valentine's-Day" category are bitter singletons who don't have a significant other with whom to toast Cupid, think again. Plenty of happily-coupled people don't care about the day, or actively take a dislike to it themselves.
"While I love a grand romantic gesture, I prefer an original gesture that's inspired by our relationship rather than a commercially-manufactured idea of what's romantic," says Dean Lofton, an Austin publicist and writer who has been married to musician and composer Jeff Lofton for six years. This year on Feb. 14, Jeff will be playing a gig at Zed's while Dean stays home writing.
"Love is much bigger than what's easily picked up from romantic comedies and the simple ideas. Imagine if our culture focused on self-love the same amount of time and energy as romantic love. So many people would be happier and have more self-confidence."
"The unexpected piece of jewelry, not prompted by massive ad campaigns, means much more to me," she says. "We also think love should be consistently expressed, not reserved for just one day."
Jeff agrees: "I prefer to get my lovin' year round."
Dean is also very aware of what lessons her ten-year-old stepdaughter is learning about love. "I want to lessen the impact of the cultural focus on romantic relationships — which is often pushed as the main focus and purpose of women's lives. Love is much bigger than what's easily picked up from romantic comedies and the simple ideas. Imagine if our culture focused on self-love the same amount of time and energy as romantic love. So many people would be happier and have more self-confidence."
It's not just Americans who feel this way, either. Across the pond, Brit Nadia Latif is even more adamant. "Our relationship is personal to us — what the hell has a designated day got to do with it? It's cheesy beyond words; I can think of no less romantic evening than one spent with thirty other couples in a stressed-out restaurant decked out with love hearts. Yuk."
She and her partner, Jordan, have been together three years and have never celebrated Valentine's Day. Nadia says it was fantastic to realize their mutual dislike of the day when their first Feb. 14 together rolled around.
"It's romance for lazy people," she states bluntly.
Kat Tancock, a writer and yoga instructor in Toronto, is also no fan of forced merriment. "I'm kind of anti-Halloween and New Year's as well, and luckily my partner agrees with me for the most part. For Valentine's Day specifically, I find it annoying that we're supposed to do something romantic with each other. Only once a year?"
"It's romance for lazy people."
She also dislikes the obligatory gift-giving aspect that comes with such holidays. (A philosophy I whole-heartedly agree with — this viewpoint has led to me being labeled a Scrooge by my family, who celebrate every single holiday with gusto, but that's another story.)
"From an environmental and economical perspective, these holidays have proliferated as an excuse to spend money, which kind of drives me crazy," Kat adds. "And every year the bar seems to go higher. My style is to be more spontaneous and give gifts and do special dinners when I feel like it, rather than when the world tells me to. It's also just so cheesy, getting flowers on Valentine's Day. It doesn't make me feel any more loved — I mean, how lame is it to expect the man in your life to buy you flowers on a certain day of the year? It's not especially creative!"
Lifestyle and relationship coach Kim Evazians says that when such expectations lead to a partner feeling forced or obligated to prove his or her feelings, it can be detrimental. "Valentine's Day isn't something we avoid. It's fine and wonderful, but if someone put that effort into a totally random day the impact would be significantly greater, because it wasn't expected at all."
Some couples seem to learn this from each other. Julie Schwietert got a lesson in both love and cultural differences from her Cuban husband, Francisco Collazo. In the first year of their relationship, Julie spent holidays silently stewing over the fact that her partner apparently did not realize these days were special; that they were supposed to be observed and recognized as days set apart from every other day of the year. "They did have Valentine's Day in Cuba, didn't they?"
By the time her birthday arrived, Julie was determined that she wasn't going to let another special day go by uncelebrated. She sulked until late afternoon, hoping Francisco would ask why she was so sullen and moody. When he finally did, she was even more livid that it had taken him so long to inquire.
"Because. It's. My. Birthday," Julie responded, every word punctuated with a period for emphasis. "And you forgot."
Francisco took the opportunity to finally explain his concept of holidays. Because he treated every day as if it was special — "And he really does," Julie adds — the days that greeting card companies and calendars and governments declared as "special" held little, if any, meaning for him. "I celebrate your birth every day," Francisco told Julie; and she knew he meant it.
"Other couples may go out for a special dinner on Valentine's Day," she says. "Maybe he'll bring her roses. But why wait for February 14? Living with Francisco helped teach me that."
And in case you're wondering about me — my partner and I don't celebrate Valentine's Day either. In fact, on this one he will be more than 9,000 miles away in Cambodia. I think we'll make our own romance, in our own way — and on a day of our choosing. If you feel the same, you might check out CultureMap's Valentine's Day events for people who hate Valentine's Day.