Movie Review
Sylvester Stallone's bet on himself pays off again in I Play Rocky
Anthony Ippolito in I Play Rocky.
There have been many movies about the process of making movies in film history, but relatively few actually depict real events. Rocky was an underdog story both on and off screen for writer/star Sylvester Stallone, and the parallels between the actor and the character make the idea of reliving that history in I Play Rocky almost irresistible.
In the early ‘70s, Stallone (Anthony Ippolito) was a struggling actor, getting by on bit parts and even agreeing to do a softcore porn film to make ends meet. As depicted in the film, his life starts to change when he meets his future wife, Sasha (AnnaSophia Robb), who encourages him to keep pursuing his dreams, especially on the writing side. The two move from New York to Los Angeles, where their proximity to the center of the movie business proves fateful.
Stallone writes multiple screenplays, with one getting that attention of producers Irwin Winkler (P.J. Byrne) and Robert Chartoff (Toby Kebbell). Even though they don’t buy that one, they encourage him to keep going, and soon Stallone finds inspiration in a boxing match between Muhammad Ali and Chuck Wepner, where the underdog Wepner lasts much longer than anyone expected. Stallone quickly writes Rocky, which the producers love, but also insists on starring in the film, which they don’t.
Directed by Peter Farrelly and written by Peter Gamble, the film takes a page from its inspiration and becomes an old-fashioned crowd-pleaser in all the best ways. The first and most obvious way is how easy it is to think that Ippolito is actually a young Stallone. It’s not five minutes into the film before his physical and voice imitation becomes scarily believable. Once that part locks in, the rest of the film falls into place as well, with few false notes cropping up over the two-hour running time.
The prime audience for the film is those who saw Rocky when it first came out or those who grew up watching it on cable, but Farrelly and Gamble do a great job of making the film entertaining even if you don’t have Rocky memorized. The gamble that Stallone made on himself in spite of high-powered people trying to get him to cave is a moving one. The filmmakers complement that element with a good amount of humor, keeping the story light and approachable.
The film even comes with some revelations for non-film historians, including the relative uniqueness of Stallone writing himself a lead role, especially as someone who had never starred in a film before. It also details the invention of Steadicam, a smooth camera operating system that was just starting to be used the year Rocky was made. Those and other behind the scenes elements make the film even more compelling.
The fact that Ippolito is starring in a film for the first time adds a meta-cherry on top of his fantastic performance, giving him another connection to Stallone. Robb leads the way in an outstanding supporting cast, as Byrne, Kebbel, Tracy Letts, Jay Duplass, Matt Dillon, Stephan James, and more bring the era to life in satisfying ways.
Farrelly, who bafflingly won two Oscars with Green Book, has delivered a winner that deserves the praise with I Play Rocky. The rags-to-riches story of Stallone mirrors the one that he created for himself in Rocky, and the experience of watching him and others create the film is heartwarming, funny, and nostalgic.
---
I Play Rocky opens wide in theaters on November 20.

A dance number from an earlier Over the Lege show at the Scottish Rite Theater in 2024.Steve Rogers Photography for Over the Lege
Over the Lege creator Stephanie Chiarello, a Capitol staffer and former principal dancer with Austin Contemporary Ballet, belts out a number.Steve Rogers Photography for Over the Lege